Sarah Kieffer

   136 Reviews
650 Main Street
East Aurora, NY 14052
(716) 652-1234
Visit Website

Recent Reviews:


East Aurora, NY
Sarah was amazing from start to finish. She found us our dream home, and she sold our home quickly and for more than we had hoped for! She made the whole process feel EASY! Sarah is the best in the biz!
Report a concern

Orchard Park, NY
Sarah was an absolute joy to work with! Her cheery attitude and prompt service made the home-buying process simple and easy. I would not have thought it was possible, but she made us even more excited to buy our first home!
Report a concern

Alden, NY
Couldn't ask for a better real estate agent than Sarah Kieffer! Very knowledgable and informative about all the ins and outs of the home buying/ selling process. From finding prospective houses, to the bidding and all the way to closing; Sarah was incredibly helpful and informative. She knows her stuff and helped make the complex process of purchasing a home as easy to understand and smooth as possible. Liked her so much we turned right around and had her list our previous home. No surprise, already sold! A++
Report a concern

Marilla, NY
Sarah was incredibly patient with us. We are very picky and she took the time to understand our needs and guide us through each home. We toured over a hundred homes, easily. We navigated COVID and adding another child to our family which changed our needs in terms of number of bedrooms. At one point, we placed and offer that we rescinded. Sarah handled this with grace and understanding. Sarah goes above and beyond to ensure we received the best offer and helped us get all of our ducks in a row for closing. She is the best!
Report a concern

Alden, NY
Sarah was just incredible. From supporting us in looking for a new home, to helping us sell our current house, Sarah was there to guide us every step of the way. She took a client-centered approach, taking the time to listen to our needs and wants, and helped us to reach and exceed our expectations. I would recommend Sarah to anyone looking to sell or buy a home. You will not be disappointed!
Report a concern

Corfu, NY
Sarah is so down the earth, honest and passionate about her job! She is so great to work with. She helped us buy our first home and now our forever home. Both processes were a breeze with her help. I would highly recommend Sarah if you want reliable help with buying or selling a home!
Report a concern

Alden, NY
Working with Sarah has been great! She is knowledgeable, personable and flexible! Listened to all our new home hopes and answered all of our first time home buyer questions with patience and without judgement! We are so incredibly grateful! Thanks Sarah!
Report a concern

West Seneca, NY
Answered fast and honestly
Report a concern

Varysburg, NY
Sarah goes above and beyond. From start to finish she is great!
Report a concern

Attica, NY
I cannot possibly say enough about my experience with Sarah! Buying, selling, looking, listing, it doesn't matter, she excels at it all. I trust her professionally and personally and am so very lucky to have her as my realtor. She does everything she can to make the process as easy and painless as possible. She really is the best!
Report a concern

Attica, NY
We loved working with [FIRST NAME REMOVED], and on a less than ideal closing situation she did a great job!
Report a concern

Angola, NY
Sarah was amazing I refer her to everyone I know; I dragged this poor girl around every town in WNY. She was so patient and friendly. So helpful!!
Report a concern

Pavilion, NY
There are countless reasons that Sarah is the top agent in the region month after month, and has been my choice of agent for the past 2 home purchases . She is accommodating , knowledgeable, relatable, and honest. I couldn't imagine going through this process with anyone else other than Sarah.
Report a concern

Cheektowaga, NY
Sarah was absolutely amazing and made our first home buying experience seamless. She always made sure to hear our concerns and make it seem like we were her only clients. Whenever someone is in need of a real estate agent, Sarah will always be the first and only suggestion we give!
Report a concern

Attica, NY
Sarah was excellent to work with. Very knowledgeable with practical information about housing prices in my neighborhood and what was occurring in the market. She was always accessible and answered all of my questions in a timely matter.
Report a concern

Porter, NY
Look no further, Sarah is the best Realtor there is for Western NY! I'll recommend her any time, anywhere!
Report a concern

Cheektowaga, NY
Great experience!
Report a concern

Aurora, NY
Found us the perfect house before it hit the market and communicated with us through the whole process. We'll be using her again for sure!
Report a concern

Elma, NY
Sarah quickly helped us find all of the answers to our questions. It was a pleasure working with her.
Report a concern

Aurora, NY
Answers all questions immediately. So helpful in every aspect and easy to talk to! Had a great experience. Would recommend her every time.
Report a concern